BANKERS AND SHIPPERS COMPANY, Plaintiff, v. EAST COAST LAND DEVELOPMENT, et al., Defendants.
1 Fla. L. Weekly Supp. 267c
Civil procedure — Interpleader by insurance company is not appropriate under facts of instant case involving competing claims to policy proceeds by persons who are themselves plaintiffs in various personal injury actions against insured
BANKERS AND SHIPPERS COMPANY, Plaintiff, v. EAST COAST LAND DEVELOPMENT, et al., Defendants. 4th Judicial Circuit in and for Duval County, FL, Division CV-C. Case No. 92-17328-CA. February 12, 1993. Peter L. Dearing, Judge. Gerald W. Weedon for Plaintiff. Robert E. O’Quinn, Jr. and Keith W. Jones for East Coast Land Development. Thomas F. Slater for Earleen Joiner. Gary C. Pajcic for Mary Lorraine Heller and Cheryl A. Revell. Dale G. Westling for Charles F. Polochak. Thomas S. Edwards, Jr., for Delores C. Jones, owner of East Coast.
ORDER GRANTING MOTIONS TO DISMISS
This cause came on for hearing on the several Defendants’ Motions to Dismiss the Amended Complaint. Upon consideration of the pleadings and argument of counsel, the Court finds as follows:
(a) The Amended Complaint states a cause of action for interpleader whereby an insurance company asks for leave to interplead its policy limits into the registry of the Court to be fought over by several competing Defendants who are themselves plaintiffs in various personal injury actions against the insured of the Plaintiff insurance company in the instant case.
(b) It is perfectly logical and sensible that an insurance company should be able to interplead its proceeds and absolve itself of any further responsibility under these circumstances. This sensible approach has been followed by the United States Supreme Court, State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. v. Tashire, 386 U.S. 523 (1967), and in several Federal Circuit and District Court cases.
(c) However, the trial courts of Florida are bound to follow Florida Appellate Court decisions in matters of civil procedure, even when they are in conflict with Federal decisions on similar or identical Federal procedural rules. State trial courts must follow the dictates of intermediate Florida appellate courts even when they are not from the district court in which the sitting circuit court is located. Pardo v. State, 596 So.2d 665 (Fla. 1992).
(d) In Florida, two other district courts have spoken on the instant issue and have determined that interpleader by an insurance company is not appropriate under the circumstances presented in the instant case. Hernandez v. Travelers Insurance Co., 356 So.2d 1342 (Fla. 3d DCA 1978); Manchester Insurance and Indemnity Co. v. Mathews, 312 So.2d 777 (Fla. 2d DCA 1975).
(e) In the instant case, this Court is not permitted to follow logic, reason, or federal precedent because it is bound by the Florida appellate decisions in virtually indistinguishable circumstances.
Accordingly, it is
ORDERED:
The Motions to Dismiss are hereby granted, and this action is hereby dismissed.
* * *
We use cookies to enhance your experience, analyze traffic, and support marketing. Manage your preferences anytime.
Manage your cookie preferences below:
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
CleanTalk offers effective spam protection and website security solutions to enhance user experience.
Service URL: cleantalk.org (opens in a new window)
This cookie is strictly necessary for website security. It is used by the CleanTalk anti-spam plugin to prevent malicious bot requests, protect forms, and ensure network management.
Service URL: cleantalk.org (opens in a new window)
Google reCAPTCHA helps protect websites from spam and abuse by verifying user interactions through challenges.
Google Tag Manager simplifies the management of marketing tags on your website without code changes.
UserWay is an AI-powered accessibility widget that scans a website for WCAG and ADA accessibility issues and gives visitors on-page tools to adjust contrast, font size, navigation, and other display settings.
Service URL: userway.org (opens in a new window)
WP Consent API is a plugin that standardizes the communication of accepted consent categories between plugins.
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us understand how visitors use our website.
Google Analytics is a powerful tool that tracks and analyzes website traffic for informed marketing decisions.
Service URL: policies.google.com (opens in a new window)
Google reCAPTCHA helps protect websites from spam and abuse by verifying user interactions through challenges.
Marketing cookies are used to follow visitors to websites. The intention is to show ads that are relevant and engaging to the individual user.
Facebook Pixel is a web analytics service that tracks and reports website traffic.
Service URL: www.facebook.com (opens in a new window)
Google Ads is an online advertising platform that enables businesses to create targeted ads displayed on Google search results and partner sites.
Service URL: policies.google.com (opens in a new window)
You can find more information in our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.